No results found.
Try adjusting or resetting your filters.
{{ agent?.kind }}
{{ agent?.firstname }} {{ agent?.lastname }}
{{ agent?.type }}
{{ agent?.office?.officename }}
{{ agent?.office?.officeaddress }}
Office {{ formatPhoneString(agent?.office?.phone) }}
Cell. {{ formatPhoneString(agent?.cellphone) }}
Languages: {{ agent?.languagesNames }}
{{ agent?.text }}
{{ agent?.biography }}
{{agent?.rating}}
{{agent?.reviews?.length ?? 0}} Reviews
{{ review.created_at }}
{{ review.name }}
{{ agent?.firstname }} {{ agent?.lastname }} currently has no active listings.

457 St Pauls Ave, Staten Island, NY 10304

Listed Price: $469,000
Sold Price: $450,000
3 Bed / 2 Bath , 1,250 Sq Ft · Single Family

Beautiful 3 Bedroom/ 2 Bathroom/ turn-of-the-century Italianate home on desirable St. Paul’s Ave. aka. Mud Lane. Nestled among other historic homes, (yet not within the St. Paul’s Historic District, so no NYC Landmarks Preservation Commission approval needed for exterior work), this house is a true gem. Many original details await within, featuring hardwood floors throughout, high ceilings, plaster ceiling medallions, beautiful original wood doors, (including a spectacular heavy paneled front door with working original doorbell), original wood newel-post/stair rail/spindles and door/window casings with rosettes, etc. Other features include an eat-in kitchen with a small sun-room, a sunny master bedroom with a view, a separate small office or closet room on the second floor, as well as two additional bedrooms and a full basement with a recently renovated full bathroom, (with a claw-foot vintage tub), and a high ceiling that opens out to an enchanted rear/side yard space (see photos). Note: dining room is currently set-up and being used as an additional bedroom, (see photo descriptions). Here is your chance to own a lovely historic home in the Mud Lane/ Stapleton Heights area with all the warmth and charm of well-maintained vintage details inside.

Building type: Detached

Residential Features:

  • Dryer
  • Washer
{{ property.neighbourhood?.name }}
{{ property.borough?.name }}
{{ property.projectname }}

{{ property.address }}

MLS #{{ property.mlsnumber }}
OPEN HOUSE: {{ property.openhouse[0].openhousedate }}, {{ property.openhouse[0].starttime }} - {{ property.openhouse[0].endtime }}

{{ property.listprice | toCurrency }}

Selling agent commission: {{ property.co_broke_commission| toCurrency }}
Selling agent commission: {{ property.co_broke_commission }}{{ property.co_broke_commission_type }}
Days on Market: {{ property.dom }}
Expiration Date: {{ property.expireddate }}
Listed Price: {{ property.listprice | toCurrency }}
Sold Price: {{ property.closeprice | toCurrency }}
Days on Market: {{ property.dom }}
Close Date: {{ property.closedate }}
Listed Price: {{ property.listprice | toCurrency }}
Closed Price: {{ property.closeprice | toCurrency }}
Days on Market: {{ property.dom }}
Close Date: {{ property.closedate }}
Under Contract: {{ property.lastchangedate }}

{{ property.publicremarks }}

{{ property.propertyType }}
Floor: {{ property.floornumber }}
Year built: {{ property.yearbuilt }}
Period built: {{ property.periodbuilt }}
Building type: {{ property.buildingtype }}
Pets Allowed: {{ property.petsallowed }}
Style: {{ property.style }}
Assessment included
Board approval included
Building amenities:
  • {{ amenity }}
Residential Features:
  • {{ feature }}
Commercial Features Interior:
  • {{ feature }}
Utilities:
  • {{ utility }}
Parking Attributes:
  • {{ parkingattribute }}
Parking Features:
  • {{ property.parkingfeaturesingle }}
  • {{ parkingfeature }}
Basement amenities:
  • {{ basementamenity }}
Exterior:
  • {{ exteriorItem }}
All listings are subject to errors, omissions, price change, withdrawal and sale without notice.
Data source copyright: © 2026 BROOKLYNMLS USA. All rights reserved.
{{ property.propertysubtype }}
Bedrooms: {{ property.bedstotal }}
Baths Full: {{ property.bathsfull }}
Baths Half: {{ property.bathshalf }}
Rooms: {{ property.roomcount }}
Stories: {{ property.stories }}
Building Size: {{ property.buildingwidth }}' x {{ property.buildinglength }}'
Lot: {{ property.lotsizewidth }}' x {{ property.lotsizelength }}'
Finished Sq. Ft.: {{ property.sqfttotal | toLocaleFormat }}
CC/Maintenance: {{ property.maintenancecommonfee | toCurrency }}
RE Tax: {{ property.taxamount | toCurrency }}
Families #: {{ property.numberoffamilies }}
Contacts
{{ agent?.kind }}
{{ agent?.firstname }} {{ agent?.lastname }}
{{ agent?.type }}
{{ agent?.officename }}
{{ agent?.officeaddress }}
Office {{ formatPhoneString(agent?.officephone) }}
Cell. {{ formatPhoneString(agent?.cellphone) }}
Languages: {{ agent?.languages }}
{{ agent?.text }}
Mortgage Calculator

{{ calc.monthly }}

{{ property.matrix_unique_id }}